Timeless Treasures for Every Collector

Discover premium figurines and toys shipped with love from our family to yours.

Shop by Category

Non Sale Items

Trending Now

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Bianca the Cat - Lying Down

$15.00

$4.50

Ty Beanie Baby: Bongo the Monkey - Brown Tail

$10.00

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Batty the Brown Bat

$15.00

$4.50

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Blessed the Praying Bear - Bon-Ton & Elder-Beerman Exclusive

$5.00

$1.50

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Baby Boy the Bear - with baseball

$5.00

$1.50

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Blizzard the White Tiger

$6.00

$1.80

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Alberta Wild Rose the Bear

$9.00

$2.70

-70%

Ty Beanie Baby: Amber the Cat

$13.00

$3.90

What Our Customers Say

★★★★★

“The packaging was incredibly secure and my order arrived two days earlier than expected. Truly impressive service.”

Sarah M.

★★★★★

“Finding high-quality items at these prices is rare. Treasure Keeper is now my go-to for unique gifts.”

David L.

★★★★★

“I had a small issue with my address, but their support team resolved it within minutes. Highly recommended.”

Elena R.

Ready to Get Started?

Join thousands of happy customers

Shop Now